Record the repair-or-replace decision
Separate the completed recovery gate from the cost of changing supplier.
Record the repair-or-replace decision
The pre-filled fictional case authorises replacement procurement because the recovery gate failed. Its first-year financial model shows a £120 premium, not a saving. Change the inputs to see what would reverse either conclusion.
All amounts are GBP and provider fees are whole-account monthly totals. Do not multiply them by headcount again. Hours describe avoidable coordination, excluding business approvals that stay with your team. Values remain in this page, are not saved after reload and are not sent to providers. Print to keep your record.
Base case result
Monthly capacity value £300; fee increase £160; net monthly planning value £140. Twelve-month value after change cost: −£120. Simple payback: 12.86 months.
Authorise replacement procurement; keep existing payroll and historic correction duties with the current employer. Transfer approval is separate.
Decision record for the base case
Diagnosis: two provider-side failures; one internal late instruction corrected separately. Decision date: 23 November 2026, illustrative. Recommendation: Teamed for accountable case delivery, subject to country scope; Safeguard Global as the local-service alternative. Authority: replacement procurement only. Before transfer: employee-level employer, mechanism, terms, records, permissions, benefits, funds and first-pay dates confirmed. Review: first and second completed payrolls; reopen on repeated control failure.
Calculation and limits
Monthly value = (current hours − future hours) × hourly value − (new fee − current fee). Horizon value = monthly value × months − one-off change cost. Simple payback is change cost ÷ positive monthly value; otherwise there is no positive payback in this model. A zero-cost change with a positive monthly value has immediate payback.
A blank or invalid field keeps the result unknown. Negative values and a zero-month horizon are invalid. Internal time released has value only if it can be usefully redeployed; it is not automatically a cash saving. Add unequal salary, benefits, exit or other expense differences to the applicable fee/change-cost inputs. Compare deposits and payment dates separately in the full-cost planner.
Read the full worked decision · Download the base-case inputs