People Ops Buyer / Purchase decisions
One foreign hire is not an HRIS replacement project
Approve the smaller purchase in the base case. A UK business with 75 staff and functioning HR software needs employment service for one proposed overseas employee. Over 12 months, the fictional retention scope costs £14,100 against £16,320 for consolidation. Buy the missing service and retain the working HRIS unless the replacement proposal changes that result or supplies an essential capability the incumbent lacks.
Read the assumptions before the result
These are fictional GBP inputs for comparing purchase scopes, with no provider names attached to prices. The buyer keeps its existing UK payroll service in both options. Both options are assumed to pass the same employment, security and required-work gates. The internal labour rate is an assumed £45/hour; it represents capacity cost, not an extra supplier invoice. Admin hours are assumptions to test after purchase, not promised savings.
The model excludes salaries, statutory employer costs, benefits, VAT, deposits, payroll funding, FX/payment charges, current-contract exit charges and any other optional product. Some may differ materially: complete those quote lines before an actual award. Do not assume they cancel or equal zero. The model decides only the defined software/service scope, not the entire hiring budget.
| Cost input | A: retain HRIS + EOR service | B: replace HRIS + EOR service |
|---|---|---|
| Incumbent HRIS | £450 × 12 = £5,400 | Replaced; new suite £400 × 12 = £4,800 |
| EOR service fee | £650 × 12 = £7,800 | £600 × 12 = £7,200 |
| Implementation labour | 8 hours × £45 = £360 | 70 hours × £45 = £3,150 |
| Old HRIS during parallel run | £0 additional: already retained above | 2 months × £450 = £900 |
| Residual administration | 1 hour/month × £45 × 12 = £540 | 0.5 hour/month × £45 × 12 = £270 |
| Year-one selected-scope total | £14,100 | £16,320 |
| Increment above current HRIS baseline of £5,400 | £8,700 | £10,920 |
Why the apparently cheaper bundle loses
A’s recurring scope cost is £450 + £650 + £45 = £1,145/month, plus £360 implementation. B’s is £400 + £600 + £22.50 = £1,022.50/month, plus £3,150 migration and £900 old-system overlap. B saves £122.50/month after transition but starts £3,690 behind. £3,690 ÷ £122.50 = 30.12 months; on whole-month comparisons, B first becomes cheaper at month 31. That horizon assumes fees and scope remain unchanged.
What reverses the choice?
| Changed assumption | Recalculated result | Decision effect |
|---|---|---|
| B suite fee falls from £400 to £200/month | B year one: £13,920; A: £14,100. | B is £180 lower; choose consolidation only if its extra transition remains acceptable and all gates pass. |
| Use unchanged inputs over 36 months | A: £41,580; B: £40,860. | B is £720 lower. Renewal prices and continuing scope could reverse this small advantage. |
| Base year-one suite-fee threshold | At £215/month B equals A at £14,100. | Below £215, B is cheaper on the included inputs; no universal supplier-price threshold is implied. |
| Proposed overseas hire is cancelled | No new employer-service gap remains. | Do not buy either EOR scope. Retain the working HRIS and UK payroll. |
| Existing HRIS fails a mandatory requirement | A no longer passes the required-work gate. | Cost cannot rescue an ineligible option; evaluate a suitable replacement. |
Change the fictional inputs
Calculations run in this browser. Download saves the displayed model inputs and result as JSON. No data is sent; reloading restores the fictional defaults. Empty or invalid inputs produce no recommendation.
Approval record: completed example
Buyer: UK People lead; 75 existing UK staff; one proposed Spain-based customer-success hire. Decision: retain HRIS and UK payroll, procure one eligible EOR service. Reason: the unmet jobs concern employing and supporting the overseas hire; the incumbent records workflow works. Budget comparison: £8,700 incremental selected-scope cost for A over the £5,400 HRIS baseline. Not yet authorised: the hire, actual supplier contract, full employment budget or payment schedule.
Required before award: named employing party and role eligibility; actual salary/benefits/funding/exit terms; security permissions; service duties and exclusions; comparable supplier quotes. Review trigger: new compulsory HRIS requirement, removal of at least £185/month from B’s suite fee, or a longer credible horizon that changes the calculation.
Sources and method
Primary product descriptions establish published scope. Recommendations apply that scope to the stated purchase; prices in the worked model are fictional inputs. Sources checked 18 November 2026.